Some songs simply do not have the same impact without the right instrumentation. For example, a lot of electronic, pop, and techno songs are not nearly as exciting without the synths, drum machines, and whatever other samples or electronic music is used.
Sometimes it's because the music is too simple without all the extra bells and whistles that come with a cool sample or two (or a hundred). Is this bad or wrong? Does it mean the song is bad? This is just my opinion, but I don't think it does. I think we see the same thing with rock music, too. A lot of the impact in rock music comes from heavy, distorted guitars, and loud drums. Take away the drums and the distortion and you're sometimes left with something... a little less than exciting.
"We Will Rock You" by Queen is not nearly as interesting when you're the only one stomping and clapping, but "We Are the Champions" would sound great with only a solo piano or guitar, as long as you've got some great vocals.
How to write with the mix in mind
As a songwriter, use this knowledge to your advantage. If you want a song that sounds strong no matter what, make sure that the piano or guitar part is strong enough to stand by itself, make sure you've got a killer melody, and make the song as interesting as possible.
You can also use this info to your benefit in the opposite direction: if you're feeling stuck while writing, try something simple (a simple guitar riff, melody, or what have you), and loop it. Then add something on top, and keep doing that until you feel you've got a song started.
As always, never let anything keep you from writing! Keep at it.
No comments:
Post a Comment